We decided to get into the hotly debated topic of the Walk/Trot division within our stock horse show industry. Given the significant attention and discussion this subject has garnered, particularly in amateur circles, we felt it was time to bring together a diverse group of voices to share their perspectives and solutions.
Joining us for this roundtable were Katy Barrett, Jessica Heyen, Ellen Beguelin, and Randall Roser, who each offered invaluable insights based on their experiences. Below is a comprehensive summary of our discussions, key points, and proposed solutions.
Introduction: Setting the Stage
Liz kicked off the conversation by emphasizing the importance of this roundtable discussion, noting that it's been a long time coming due to the passionate debates surrounding the Walk/Trot division.
Katy Barrett introduced herself, highlighting her extensive background in both aviation and equine industries. She discussed her return to the horse show world, particularly her focus on the Pinto shows. Jessica Heyen shared her journey from central Illinois, working within the USDA and showing APHA, while Ellen Beguelin talked about her role as a high school special ed teacher and her experiences in the paint horse circuit. Randall Roser, an announcer and horse show manager, added a unique perspective from the logistical side of managing horse shows.
The Core Debate: Temporary Stepping Stone or Permanent Option?
Jenna posed a fundamental question: Should Walk/Trot classes be a temporary stepping stone or a permanent option for riders with physical or financial limitations?
Katy’s Perspective:
- Katy emphasized that while Walk/Trot is essential, especially for those with physical limitations, she is worried about it becoming a comfort zone for many who could move beyond it.
- She proposed the idea of adding more structure, like having a novice division with a point cap.
Randall’s View:
- Randall argued that financial constraints shouldn't be a decisive factor, suggesting that other disciplines manage to maintain participation without diluting class quality.
- He favored a solution similar to what is seen in the reining horse industry, where beginner classes are challenging yet attainable.
Jessica and Ellen’s Input:
- Both Jessica and Ellen shared personal anecdotes, revealing the real-life implications and benefits of the Walk/Trot division for riders who may not have the means or physical capability to compete in lope classes.
- They supported the idea of keeping Walk/Trot accessible but were open to discussions on how to limit potential abuses of the system.
Addressing Abuse and Balancing the Division
A significant part of the discussion centered on potential abuses of the Walk/Trot division. The group recognized that some participants might exploit the system for competitive advantage, staying in Walk/Trot classes when they could compete in higher divisions.
Balanced Solutions:
- Katy suggested a flexible structure where participants could compete in both Walk/Trot and Walk/Trot/Canter classes until they reached a certain point threshold, which would encourage progression without pressure.
- Randall emphasized the need for stringent rules but was open to Katy’s flexible intermediate approach, suggesting it could be viable if similar systems were adopted across associations.
The Future of Walk/Trot: Flexibility and Growth
One major takeaway was the consensus that Walk/Trot has become an indispensable part of the horse show world, especially in bringing new people into the sport and keeping the numbers up at regional shows.
Integrating Flexibility:
- The roundtable discussed allowing more class crossovers, similar to AQHA, where riders could show in both Walk/Trot and higher divisions, potentially increasing participation across the board.
- Katy, Jessica, and Ellen were particularly vocal about making the system more inclusive without overly restrictive rules, ensuring the longevity and vitality of the Walk/Trot classes.
Conclusion: Moving Forward
Concluding the roundtable, each participant shared their closing thoughts:
Katy Barrett: Reiterated the need for progressive thinking and flexibility in rules to foster growth and inclusivity.
Jessica Heyen: Emphasized creating a safe and inclusive environment for all exhibitors.
Ellen Beguelin: Advocated for the continued importance of Walk/Trot while being open to competitive improvements.
Randall Roser: Highlighted the necessity of rules but stressed encouraging exhibitors to progress beyond Walk/Trot.
The episode wrapped up with appreciation for the robust discussion and a hopeful tone that the industry can adapt and grow through thoughtful dialogue and innovative solutions.
For more in-depth insights and to listen to the full episode, check out the links at the top of the page. Your feedback and comments are highly encouraged as we navigate these complex yet crucial discussions.
WANT TO BE A SPONSOR FOR OTR?
Are you looking to connect with a passionate and engaged audience in the stock horse show industry? Sponsoring On The Rail Podcast offers a unique opportunity to showcase your brand to dedicated equestrians, top competitors, and industry professionals. Our podcast delivers in-depth discussions, exclusive interviews, and valuable insights that resonate with listeners who are deeply invested in the world of stock horse shows. By becoming a sponsor, you align your brand with quality content and gain access to a niche market eager to discover products and services that enhance their equestrian experience. Reach out to us today to explore how we can partner to elevate your brand and engage with our dynamic audience!
Being a Super Select (70+) with physical limitations both myself and horse (can't lope).....Walk trot is the only division I can show. My problem especially with AQHA is we spend our time and money at shows and get W/T points, but they don't really get you or your horse anywhere....ie...no ROM's, titles, etc.